On 3 November 1998 the preliminary investigations judge ruled that he did not have jurisdiction ratione materiae and sent the file back to the public prosecutor's office.

The Court of Appeal had found that the arbitral tribunal lacked ratione materiae jurisdiction, but that its jurisdiction ratione personae had been established.

Venezuela considered that the arbitral tribunal wrongly upheld its jurisdiction ratione personae and ratione materiae.

(f) Declaration of lack of jurisdiction ratione materiae made on 19 April 1991 by the İdil public prosecutor

In its answer of December 16th 2006, X_ objected to the jurisdiction ratione materiae of the Arbitral Tribunal.

In its answer of December 16th 2006, X_ objected to the jurisdiction ratione materiae of the Arbitral Tribunal.

Dismisses by six votes to one the remainder of the Government's preliminary objection of incompatibility ratione materiae;

The public prosecutor had declared that he had no jurisdiction ratione materiae and had returned the case file to the Şırnak Administrative Council.

The applicant insisted, in line with her submissions concerning the preliminary objection ratione materiae (Loizidou judgment (preliminary objections) cited above at paragraph 32, pp. 22-23, paras.

The applicant insisted, in line with her submissions concerning the preliminary objection ratione materiae (Loizidou judgment (preliminary objections) cited above at paragraph 32, pp. 22-23, paras.

In his order of 21 July 1993 declining jurisdiction ratione materiae, the Şırnak public prosecutor stated that he was forwarding the file to the Şırnak Administrative Council.

On the other hand, admitting the objection of lack of jurisdiction ratione materiae raised by the same party, he found that he was not competent to hear the appeal filed by the Club and thus terminated the procedure.