Initially, the Appellant relied upon the previous main request and filed a number of further subsidiary requests, the previous sole subsidiary request becoming the second subsidiary request.
Consideration of the subsidiary request is therefore redundant.
The first subsidiary request can therefore be taken into account.
5.2 The second subsidiary request concerns a matter which does not arise in the present case.
This subsidiary request is directed at inserting a single word*) in Claim 1 as per the main request and was made just before the end of the oral proceedings.
Extended subject-matter: yes (main request) - no (first auxiliary request)
Claims 1 to 6 ("auxiliary request") filed on 4 August 1992 (second auxiliary request),
The decision was based on a main request and a first auxiliary request.
The main request and the first auxiliary request are rejected.
Therefore, the reasons stated above for auxiliary request 2 apply mutatis mutandis to auxiliary request 3.
During the oral proceedings on 27 October 2010, it filed an additional auxiliary claim 24.
Admissibility of main request (yes); reformatio in peius (no)
Consequently, the first auxiliary request is allowable.
Auxiliary request 4: Deletion of disclaimer: Reformatio in peius (no), Novelty (yes)
The first auxiliary request is therefore not allowable.
The auxiliary request was therefore not allowable.
Requirement of invention - method, auxiliary request 1 (yes)
Auxiliary request 1 (claims upheld by the opposition division)
Auxiliary request 1 - Inventive step (Article 56 EPC)
As a consequence auxiliary request 1 is allowable.
Auxiliary request 1, inventive step (Article 56 EPC)
First auxiliary request - support by the description (no)
Auxiliary request 1 - inventive step - yes, unexpected improvement
Consequently, the auxiliary request 1 must be refused.
Third auxiliary request - remitted to the first instance
Requêtes fréquentes français :1-200, -1k, -2k, -3k, -4k, -5k, -7k, -10k, -20k, -40k, -100k, -200k, -500k, -1000k,
Requêtes fréquentes anglais :1-200, -1k, -2k, -3k, -4k, -5k, -7k, -10k, -20k, -40k, -100k, -200k, -500k, -1000k,
Traduction Translation Traducción Übersetzung Tradução Traduzione Traducere Vertaling Tłumaczenie Mετάφραση Oversættelse Översättning Käännös Aistriúchán Traduzzjoni Prevajanje Vertimas Tõlge Preklad Fordítás Tulkojumi Превод Překlad Prijevod 翻訳 번역 翻译 Перевод